|Comparison of Thermocouples, RTDs, and Thermistors|
|Electrical temperature measurement is used in a wide variety of industries. From melting steel to baking cookies, the environment, required measurement resolution and accuracy, and temperature ranges can vary greatly and the type of sensor used to measure these temperatures must be chosen accordingly. This application note discusses the fundamentals of selecting and interfacing to temperature sensors.|
In industrial and embedded environments, it is not always practical to measure temperature locally. Often, temperature must be measured remotely at one location and then relayed back to a computer for processing and recording. This is often accomplished by connecting thermocouples, RTDs, and thermistors to a remote measurement system (such as Sensoray's model 2600 Ethernet data acquisition system, or an easily embedded interface such as the model 518 PC/104 intelligent sensor interface) that will measure the sensor signals and send the resulting data to the computer.
A thermocouple is a temperature-sensing element that converts thermal energy directly into electrical energy. In its basic form it consists of two dissimilar metallic conductors connected in a closed loop. Each junction forms a thermocouple. If one thermocouple is maintained at a temperature different from that of the other, an electrical voltage proportional to this temperature difference will be produced by the circuit. Thermocouples are interchangeable, cheap, have standard connectors, and can measure a wide range of temperatures. The main limitation of thermocouples is their accuracy; system errors of less than 1°C can be difficult to achieve.
In 1822, physicist Thomas Johann Seebeck accidentally discovered that when any conductor is subjected to a thermal gradient, it will generate a voltage. Any attempt to measure this voltage involves connecting another conductor to the "hot" end. This additional conductor will then also experience the temperature gradient, and develop a voltage of its own which will oppose the original; the magnitude of this effect depends upon the metal in use. If there is the same temperature at the two junctions there is no flow of current since the partial voltages produced at the two points cancel each other. Using a dissimilar metal to complete the circuit will have a different voltage generated, leaving a small difference voltage available for measurement, which increases with temperature. This difference can typically be between 1 to 70 µV/°C for the available range of metal combinations. Certain combinations have become popular as industry standards, driven by cost, availability, convenience, melting point, chemical properties, stability, and output.
When choosing a thermocouple, consideration should be given to the insulation, thermocouple type, and probe construction.
Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs), also referred to as platinum resistance thermometers (PRTs) or resistance thermometers, are temperature sensors that change resistance at a predetermined rate in response to variation in temperatures. RTDs are used in lieu of thermocouples in many industrial applications below 600°C due to their higher sensitivity and accuracy.
How do RTDs work?
RTDs offer greater stability, accuracy and in some cases repeatability than thermocouples. While thermocouples use the thermoelectric effect to generate a voltage, RTDs require a power source to operate and use electrical resistance. Ideally, the resistance will vary linearly with temperature.
RTDs are most often made using platinum, due to its linear resistance-temperature relationship as well as its chemical inertness. The platinum detecting wire needs to be guarded from contamination to remain stable. Commercial platinum grades are produced which exhibit a change of resistance of 0.385 Ω/°C (European Fundamental Interval) The sensor is usually made to have a resistance of 100 Ω at 0°C.
RTDs require a small current to be passed through in order to determine the resistance. This can cause self-heating so it is important to minimize the current to reduce self-heating errors. Care should also be taken to avoid any strains on the RTD in its application. Lead wire resistance should be considered, and adopting three and four wire connections can eliminate connection lead resistance effects from measurements.
RTD Wiring Configurations
Thermistors are a type of resistor with an electrical resistance that possesses either a negative or positive temperature coefficient of resistivity. Thermistors are composed of solid semiconducting materials with a resistance that decreases 4% per °C. They are constructed in a variety of sizes and may be obtained with thermal time constants of a millisecond or less. Thermistors produce a non-linear voltage and because of this are limited to a useful temperature span of only about 100°C.
Thermistors are the most accurate of the temperature sensors, ∼±0.02°C, as well as the most sensitive. Their response time is short in relation to RTDs, and about the same as thermocouples.
The resistance of thermistors is normally several orders of magnitude greater than any lead resistance. The lead resistance therefore, has a negligible effect on the temperature reading and thermistors are almost always connected in a 2-wire configuration.